Hilliard, OH Edition: DiCarlo's Original Pizza

By Candace Nelson - 9:17 PM

DiCarlos Pizza

My favorite pizza of all time, DiCarlo's, is centered primarily in the Ohio Valley, But they have some outliers - like Myrtle Beach and the Columbus area.

DiCarlos Pizza

I'm nothing if not dedicated, so I knew I wanted to knock off ALL the locations of DiCarlo's eventually - not just the ones in West Virginia. That led me to this Hilliard location.

DiCarlos Pizza

If you've been hiding under a rock (just kidding :)), DiCarlo's is Ohio Valley-style pizza - a crisp baked crust with a slightly sweet and tangy tomato sauce. Once that's baked, they sprinkle fresh mozzarella cheese on top so it gently melts. It's perfect. And controversial - because some people like their cheese to get so melted it turns into a greasy glob.

DiCarlos Pizza

The DiCarlo's locations further away from the Ohio Valley tend to be a bit more modern - with accepting debit/credit cards and having actual indoor dining. The Hilliard location follows that trend.

DiCarlos Pizza

But they do keep their menu simple - pizza, pepperoni rolls, soda. I went classic 8 cuts (or pieces) with mushrooms. Why? That's as many as typically fits in one box.

DiCarlos Pizza

So, it's pretty much the same DiCarlo's I know and love, but with just little tweaks. The mushrooms didn't have the garlic salt I love, and much of the mozzarella was very long shreds. But - still great taste.

DiCarlos Pizza

Have you tried this location?

DiCarlos Pizza

Grade: A

  • Share:

You Might Also Like

0 comments

All work property of Candace Nelson. Powered by Blogger.