Cafe Oliverio opened in mid-February 2025 in the Fort Pierpont Plaza near Cheat Lake, bringing a more contemporary, casual dining concept to one of North Central West Virginia’s best-known Italian restaurant families. The restaurant is an extension of the Oliverio family’s culinary legacy, which dates back to 1965, when Sonny and Shirley Oliverio established their original restaurant in Bridgeport. Their grandson, Patrick Oliverio, helped expand the family business into the Cheat Lake community after years of requests for a location in that area.
While Oliverio’s Ristorante in Morgantown’s Wharf District offers a more traditional Italian dining experience, Cafe Oliverio embraces a livelier, more contemporary atmosphere with a spacious bar, televisions, indoor dining areas and a covered outdoor patio with a fireplace.
The restaurant operates under the slogan “Tradition Never Stops,” reflecting its commitment to preserving generations of family recipes while introducing new dishes and dining experiences.
The menu features Italian and Italian-American favorites, including pasta, pizza, paninis, soups, salads, chicken, veal and seafood. The family’s signature marinara, meat sauce, meatballs and famous crab balls carry over from its other restaurants.
Some of the dishes that distinguish the Cheat Lake location include:
Branzino Piccata: Mediterranean whitefish served over angel hair pasta with a lemon-caper sauce.
San Giovanni Rigatoni: Short rigatoni, a blush sauce and seasoned mozzarella pearls.
Meatball Caprese Salad: Signature meatballs accompanied by homemade ricotta, fresh tomatoes and mozzarella.
New York-style pizza: Thin, crispy-crust pizza.
Burrata ravioli: Cheese-filled pasta served with a pink sauce.
I started with Oliverio’s signature breadsticks and a bowl of Italian wedding soup. The breadsticks are fresh & a fluffy - a staple of the Oliverio dining experience, while the soup is a classic Italian-American comfort food that brings together savory broth, tender little meatballs, greens and bits of pasta. The name, incidentally, has nothing to do with weddings; it comes from the Italian minestra maritata, or “married soup,” referring to the harmonious combination of meat and greens.
For my entrée, I opted for rigatoni in blush sauce with mozzarella pearls. The ridged tubes of pasta are coated in a creamy, pink-hued sauce that balances the bright acidity of tomatoes with the richness of cream. Small pearls of mozzarella add pockets of milky, delicate cheesiness throughout the dish. It's a simple but indulgent combination that falls somewhere between the heartiness of a traditional red sauce and the silky richness of an Alfredo.
Grade: A
All work property of Candace Nelson. Powered by Blogger.
0 comments