I recently heard about Penny's Sweet Confections, so I placed an order to try a bit of everything. Available cookies:

Peanut butter
Chocolate Chip peanut butter
Chocolate chip
Double Chocolate Chip
Creamsicle
Strawberry
S’mores
Snickerdoodle
These were all tasty, but my favorites were the strswberry and s'mores. Have you tried them yet?